91st and Appleton fatal shooting: Milwaukee man charged, arrested

Jaruthh Gathings

A 28-year-old Milwaukee man is charged in connection with a fatal shooting that happened near 91st and Appleton earlier this month. The accused is Jaruthh Gathings. He is arrested and faces the following criminal counts: 

  • First-degree intentional homicide
  • Possession of a firearm by a felon

According to the criminal complaint, Milwaukee police were dispatched to a shooting near 91st and Appleton on Tuesday afternoon, March 8. They found an unresponsive man "in the driver's seat of a gray Jeep that had crashed into a light pole at the intersection," the complaint says. The victim suffered multiple gunshot wounds, was taken to a hospital, and was later pronounced deceased.

Fatal shooting near 91st and Appleton, Milwaukee (March 8)

When police examined the Jeep, the complaint says physical evidence suggested "the shooter was inside the Jeep and to the right of the victim."

SIGN UP TODAY: Get daily headlines, breaking news emails from FOX6 News

Detectives recovered surveillance video from a gas station near the crash site. It shows the Jeep at a gas pump and appears to be waiting. Then, a "man from a white car, whose features match the defendant, exits the white car and enters the passenger front seat of the victim's gray Jeep. Moments later, a second man from the white car slowly approaches the gray Jeep from the rear, then suddenly rushed up to the driver's door," the complaint says. Moments later, the Jeep accelerates and crashes into a utility pole.

The complaint indicates about an hour after the crash, the defendant arrived at Froedtert Hospital with facial injuries and a broken leg.

Fatal shooting near 91st and Appleton, Milwaukee (March 8)

A woman who was with the victim prior to his going to the gas station told police "she knows (the victim) sells illegal drugs," the complaint says.

FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX6 News app for iOS or Android

The complaint notes that the defendant is a felon -- having been convicted of armed robbery in November 2012. 

Fatal shooting near 91st and Appleton, Milwaukee (March 8)


Amber Alert canceled, Milwaukee boy found safe: police

An Amber Alert issued for missing 3-month-old Anthony Crudup Jr. on Wednesday, March 23 was canceled that afternoon. He was found safe, police said.


Milwaukee County Overdose Dashboard created to understand trends

A Milwaukee County Overdose Dashboard has been created in order to understand the trends in both fatal and nonfatal overdoses and inform prevention efforts.


TSA intercepts gun at Mitchell International Airport; 7th in 2022

Transportation Security Administration officers prevented a handgun from making its way onboard an airplane at Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport on Tuesday, March 22.