Sendik's on Downer cleared to reopen, Milwaukee Health Department says

MILWAUKEE - The City of Milwaukee Health Department (MHD) announced on Wednesday, May 7 that it has cleared Nehring's Sendik’s on Downer to reopen. This comes following a thorough inspection conducted earlier in the day. 

Sendik's on Downer to reopen

What we know:

A news release says the business was issued a Closure Order on May 5, due to evidence of rodent activity in both basement storage and customer-facing areas.

FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX LOCAL Mobile app for iOS or Android

During Wednesday’s re-inspection, the Milwaukee Health Department confirmed that all pest-related violations have been addressed. Affected areas have been cleaned and sanitized, and no new pest activity was observed. 

As outlined in MHD’s policy, closures remain in effect for a minimum of one overnight period to allow for proper remediation and assessment of any ongoing activity.

MHD has issued a follow-up Intent to Cease Order, which allows its team to continue monitoring the facility in the days ahead to ensure compliance.

Officials noted that Sendik’s has been cooperative throughout the process and is now operating in compliance with public health standards.

Other issues in city?

FOX6 News asked health department officials if there has been an increase in cases like the one at Sendik's on Downer. Officials said they had issued 111 closure orders so far in 2025. That compares to 108 in 2024 during the same timeframe. 

"It's a snapshot of the last three years. When we make closures, it's really based on what we're seeing that immediate moment. So often times people can address those issues and reopen and report back," said Carly Hegarty, Director of Consumer Environmental Health at MHD.

Carly Hegarty

SIGN UP TODAY: Get daily headlines, breaking news emails from FOX6 News

Officials said most businesses work together with the health department to rectify issues. 

Statement from Nehring's Sendik's

To Our Loyal Sendik’s on Downer Patrons,

We’re happy to share that Sendik’s on Downer is open again. We’ve worked closely with the Health Department and local partners to quickly and thoroughly resolve the issue identified this week. Maintaining our long-standing "A" rating was a top priority, and we’re grateful for the opportunity to move forward.

Our historic building presents unique challenges, especially during ongoing city water and sewer work. However, the quality and safety of our food was never in question. We’ve proudly served this community for 12 years, and our dedicated team remains committed to offering the best products, service, and experience in Milwaukee.

Thank you for your patience, trust, and continued support.

With gratitude,

John & Anne Nehring

Owners, Sendik’s on Downer