Dating app 'predator' Timothy Olson says 'women lie'

A man accused of victimizing local women on dating apps says "women lie."

Timothy Olson called FOX6 Investigator Bryan Polcyn from the Milwaukee County Jail to tell his side of the story, but there were some questions he did not care to answer.

"These women lie, and everybody believes it!" said Olson in the first of three phone calls totaling nearly 40 minutes over a two-day period. 

Olson placed the calls from a phone inside the Milwaukee County Jail where he is being held on charges for kidnapping a 79-year-old woman at gunpoint in Franklin.

On Nov. 9, Racine police issued a safety alert warning women in the area that Olson meets women on dating apps "and victimizes them." Nearly two weeks later, they updated the alert to indicate that Olson had been linked to three women in different jurisdictions who had fallen unconscious in his presence. One said she believed he "roofied" her – a slang term for spiking a drink with incapacitating drugs.

SIGN UP TODAY: Get daily headlines, breaking news emails from FOX6 News

Olson denies drugging anyone's drink. He told Polcyn the women he meets simply give him things like their debit cards.

"'No. Don't worry. Take my card,'" he recounted one woman saying. "'Get money out. Go into Kwik Trip. You know, take however much you want to, $200, $300, you know, take it,'" Olson said.

When women accuse Olson of stealing their money, he said it is only because he leaves them with broken hearts. 

"She told me she loved me that night, and I didn't reciprocate," Olson said about a woman who went to police after blacking out, then finding a series of ATM withdrawals from her bank account.

At 52 years old, Olson has a long history of committing crimes dating back to the 1990s -- including forgery and theft. 

The FOX6 Investigators first chronicled Olson's predatory dating behavior in 2012 when three different women said he stole their money. One said Olson stole something far more important – vials of human growth hormone that she relied on after a debilitating car crash. Olson insists that woman gave him the medications willingly and only called police after he dumped her. He was eventually convicted of theft.

"She gave it to me, and I was only in possession. I only admitted to being in possession of it," Olson said.

Olson was convicted and served time in Illinois. Ten years later, he called FOX6 Investigator Bryan Polcyn from the Milwaukee County Jail.

FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX6 News app for iOS or Android

"I didn't roofie her!" Olson said, referring to a woman identified by Mount Pleasant Police only as KLB. A criminal complaint charges Olson with stealing KLB's identity and withdrawing $800 from her bank account. Olson said she gave him the money because she was drunk.

"Women drink a lot," Olson said. "She drank a lot. I asked her to stop."

South Milwaukee police say Olson is a person of interest in the death of another woman -- Kim Mikulance -- who friends know as Raina Reighns. She was a 55-year-old karaoke singer who lost consciousness and later died after drinking at a bar with Olson.

"OK, that’s not my fault!" Olson said. "I don’t know what she’s doing! She ended up unconscious, that’s her… that’s… what did I do to her?"

Kim Mikulance

Now, Franklin police say Olson kidnapped a 79-year-old Greendale woman at gunpoint.

"There’s no gun," Olson said. "Get out of here."

Olson claimed the woman – who is 27 years older than him – was trying to help him hide from police. She even considered renting him a hotel room, he said, then changed her mind, worried she would get caught and get into trouble. Olson admitted he may have used romance to manipulate her, too. 

"What’s the possibility that you made her think she was in love with you so you could say, ‘Hey, help hide me?'" asked FOX6 Investigator Bryan Polcyn.

"That’s not illegal," Olson said. "Is it immoral? Sure. But is it illegal? No. But that doesn’t mean I'm capable of (expletive) kidnapping."

Olson seems to have an answer for everything. Well, almost everything.

"Do you use romance to manipulate women?" Polcyn asked.

"Come on. This is ridiculous," Olson replied. "I'm not even going to answer that. I can't help it if they're wanting to do stuff for me, and I accept it."

Timothy Olson 

Olson is being held in the Milwaukee County Jail on charges related to the alleged kidnapping. He is also charged with five counts of identity theft in Racine.