Kaia Mueller sentenced, 12 years prison for bank robbery, vehicle theft

Kaia Mueller

A Waukesha County judge sentenced Kaia Mueller of Elkhorn on Thursday, March 10 to 12 years in prison and 13 years of extended supervision in connection to two Oconomowoc armed robberies, including a bank, and the alleged theft of two vehicles in June 2021.

Mueller pleaded guilty in January to three of seven charges against him including: 

  • Attempt operate without consent-possess weapon
  • Operate without consent-possess weapon
  • Robbery of a financial institution

Four other charges against him were dismissed and read into the court record for the purposes of sentencing.

The crimes

Mueller was arrested by Lake Delton police on June 30, 2021. It was a day earlier when Oconomowoc police were dispatched to the area near W. Second and S. Franklin Streets for a possible armed robbery. Police said as officers were en route, a second call came in for a vehicle theft about a block away near Second and Main. 

SIGN UP TODAY: Get daily headlines, breaking news emails from FOX6 News

A short time later, a hold-up alarm was triggered at Waukesha State Bank, nearly three miles to the south near Highway 67 and Oconomowoc Drive, and the person involved in the first two incidents matched the description of the person involved in the bank robbery.

Oconomowoc manhunt after Waukesha State Bank robbery

Law enforcement searching for a suspect after a robbery at Waukesha State Bank in Oconomowoc.

Summit police made a traffic stop on a vehicle, which crashed off of westbound I-94 near Golden Lake Road. The driver ran off into the woods.

The interstate was shut down for hours as police searched for the man, causing backups that stretched miles. Deputies in tactical gear and long guns also blocked streets in the area as the search for the suspect continued into the evening.

FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX6 News app for iOS or Android

Several hours after the robbery calls came in, police got word that a car was stolen off of Valley View Road in Oconomowoc – the vehicle police believe the suspect used as a getaway car.

Police later identified Mueller as the suspect in the strong-armed robbery and bank robbery.


Officer shot 25th and St. Paul: Milwaukee police release video

The Milwaukee Police Department on Friday, March 11 released information and video regarding a January officer-involved shooting.


Milwaukee man accused; driving drunk, fleeing police in Oak Creek

A 30-year-old Milwaukee man is accused of driving drunk and fleeing from police during a traffic stop in Oak Creek in January.


North and Holton fatal shooting: Milwaukee police investigate

Milwaukee police are on the scene of a fatal shooting near E. North Avenue and Holton on Friday evening, March 11.