Milwaukee man fatally shot 'over 25-cent cakes,' mother says

Man fatally shot 'over 25-cent cakes'

Gunned down at a Milwaukee gas station near Teutonia and Roosevelt, the family of Isaiah Allen, 29, says he died over dessert.

MILWAUKEE - Gunned down at a Milwaukee gas station near Teutonia and Roosevelt, the family of Isaiah Allen, 29, says he died over dessert on Wednesday morning, Aug. 16.

Family said Allen was stealing when someone acting as store security shot and killed him.

"That’s my firstborn son," said Natalie Easter, Allen's mother.

SIGN UP TODAY: Get daily headlines, breaking news emails from FOX6 News

"Why?" said Troy Allen, Isaiah's father. "That’s it. Just, why?"

The shooting happened around 6:30 a.m. Wednesday at the Clark gas station near Teutonia and Roosevelt.

Isaiah Allen

"He was laying on the ground," said Easter. "The tape was up, and I went through the tape."

Easter said her son suffered from mental health issues. She said before the shooting, Allen stole sweets.

"I was told he took a box of 25-cent cakes," said Easter.

Natalie Easter

After that, Easter said someone working as store security shot him.

Police said Wednesday no arrests were made, but they know who they're looking for.

"A gun shouldn’t come into play, especially over something so meaningless," said Easter. "Over 25-cent cakes. Are you for real?"

Milwaukee homicide, Teutonia and Roosevelt

Family said Allen was preparing to move to Louisville to receive support for his mental health.

"I was like, what?" said Troy Allen. "I was just there last night to bring him his clothes, so he can leave."

FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX6 News app for iOS or Android.

Police did not confirm the circumstances leading up to the shooting.

FOX6 News tried to make contact with the gas station employees Wednesday, but workers wouldn’t unlock the front doors.

Vigil for Milwaukee man killed at gas station

Gunned down at a Milwaukee gas station near Teutonia and Roosevelt, the family of Isaiah Allen, 29, says he died over dessert, shot by a man acting as store security after stealing.

"I don’t know what more to say other than he had a lot of family that loved him," said Easter. "He wasn’t supposed to leave like this."

Family blocked all of the gas pumps and the entrance to the gas station on Wednesday and planned a 6 p.m. vigil for Allen. They didn't say how long they planned on staying there.

Editor's note: Milwaukee police on Friday, Aug. 18 – after this story aired and was originally posted – announced that a 56-year-old Milwaukee man has been arrested in connection to this homicide. Criminal charges will be referred to the district attorney's office.