Milwaukee County Judge Dugan new trial, acquittal request denied

Judge Hannah Dugan enters federal court on Thursday, Dec. 18.

A request by former Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan and her defense team for a new trial and an acquittal in her case was denied by Federal Judge Lynn Adelman on Monday, April 6. 

The request for the reviews was placed in December – after Dugan was found guilty of felony obstruction. A federal jury found Dugan not guilty of a second count.

Dugan new trial denied

The backstory:

The Dugan case sparked questions about courthouse arrests, and policies surrounding I.C.E. were a significant topic during Dugan's trial. 

On April 18, 2025, federal agents said they planned to arrest Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, who was in the country illegally, in the public hallway outside Dugan's courtroom. Federal agents testified during the trial that Dugan ordered them to Chief Judge Carl Ashley's office. Ashley testified that nothing in the draft would stop I.C.E. from making arrests in public hallways, and there is no requirement for I.C.E. to check in with him.

FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX LOCAL Mobile app for iOS or Android

Milwaukee County Chief Judge Carl Ashley has said he's been working on a policy about I.C.E. at the courthouse for months.

Related

Hannah Dugan resigns, Milwaukee County judge replacement appointed

Gov. Tony Evers on Wednesday announced he has appointed a replacement to fill the Milwaukee County Circuit Court judge seat previously held by Hannah Dugan, who submitted her resignation Saturday.

The Source: Information in this post was provided by new documents and previous FOX6 News coverage.

Judge Hannah DuganCrime and Public SafetyMilwaukeeNews